REGIONAL
SEWERAGE AUTHORITY
MINUTES
Regular Meeting
April 25, 2007
The WANAQUE
VALLEY REGIONAL SEWERAGE AUTHORITY conducted a Regular Meeting, which commenced
at 6:10 P.M., in the
ANNOUNCEMENT
Chairman
Covelli read the following announcement:
This is the
Regular Meeting of the Wanaque Valley Regional Sewerage Authority. In
accordance with the Open Public Meetings Law, notices of the meeting were
furnished to the respective Municipal Clerks of Ringwood, Wanaque, and West
Milford together with a request that an additional copy of the Notice be placed
in each
SALUTE TO
THE FLAG
The Chairman
led the salute to the flag.
ROLLCALL
Commissioners Present: Andrew Bolduc, Frank Covelli, Joseph Elcavage, Robert Hadley, and Patrick Murray
Commissioners
Absent: Robert Moshman
Also Present:
Richard
Miller, Esq., Williams, Caliri, Miller & Otley
Kevin Boswell,
P.E. Boswell Engineering
Frank Rossi,
Boswell Engineering
Gregory White,
Facilities Manager
Dan Mahler,
Wanaque Mayor
Margaret Maas,
Recording Secretary
CORRESPONDENCE
Correspondence
List for March 7,2007 to April 18, 2007
The Chairman
asked if there were any questions on the Correspondence List as presented.
When there was
no response he stated that the Correspondences would be placed on file.
MINUTES
Regular
Meeting - March 28, 2007
The Chairman asked if anyone had any questions or comments on the
Regular Meeting Minutes of March 28,2007 as presented.
When there was no response the following motion was moved.
MOTION
Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd by Patrick Murray to adopt a resolution
accepting the Regular Meeting Minutes of March 28, 2007 as presented.
On Roll Call
Commissioners Bolduc, Elcavage, Hadley, Murray and
Covelli voted yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
REPORTS
Facilities
Manager
Noise and
Odor Control Report
Mr. White directed everyone to the second page of his report where there
were two new items listed under April 25, 2007 with regard to Noise Control.
Mr. White stated that one ofthe odor control units,
the one on the septage receiving area, the bearing
and the shaft went on the unit which were causing excessive noise and rumbling.
Mr. White stated that the bearing and the shaft were replaced by the
contractor, Stone Hill Contracting yesterday. Mr. White stated that the unit is
no longer producing additional noise.
Secondly, Mr. White stated that we have been turning the odor control
units off at night from approximately 9:00 pm until 6:00 am to help reduce any
potential noise during the late evening and early morning hours.
1) Media samples were taken from all bays of all odor control units on
March 1, 2007 and sent to Purafil for analysis.
REPORTS
Facilities
Manager
Noise and
Odor Control Report
Mr. White directed everyone to the last page of the
report. He stated that regarding Odor Control -last month he reported that the
odor mix media in the grit chamber unit had been found to be spent,
therefore we replaced it on the 4th of April.
Mr. White stated that scattered throughout the Pulte development and our
Interceptor Line we have carbon media inserts within the manholes. That carbon
media was changed on April 5, 2007.
Mr. White
asked if there were any questions on the report. Hearing none he moved on. Capacity
Assurance Report (CAP)
Mr. White
stated that this Authority is required to submit a quarterly CAP report to DEP.
He stated that
the most recent submittal was for the period January thru March 2007. Mr. White
stated that that report reflected that we had 106,421 gallons of capacity
available at this plant.
Mr. White stated that the next item - and you can forget what I just
said because with the April 16th storm, the facility was inundated
with excessive Inflow and Infiltration, as you can see by my letter authored to
NJDEP Enforcement Agency. On Sunday, thel5th, Monday, the16th
and Tuesday, the 1 ih we had to perform intermittent bypassing of dilute raw sewage around the
treatment facility and again it was because we were being inundated by flow
from the Inflow and
Infiltration. Mr. White stated that on a
normal day we receive about a million gallons per day
of flow, we were receiving in
excess of four million gallons per day of flow, at peale
times during the rain event. Mr. White reported that our Haskell Pump Station
(BPS) which normally pumps between 450,000 and 500,000 gallons per day of flow
was pumping well over 2,000,000 gallons per day. He stated that the entire area
surrounding the HPS was flooded and we also had the manholes adjacent to the
HPS surcharging - which means there was raw sewage coming up out ofthe manholes. He stated that it either comes up through
the holes in the manhole cover or it actually lifts the cover up off the
manhole. Mr. White stated that the surcharging lasted for several hours on
Monday.
Mr. White stated that it was nothing unusual, we have seen this in the
past- we performed the normal procedures- and we have no other choice when we
are as inundated as we were. He stated that he expects no enforcement action to
be taken against the Authority. Mr. White stated that all other facilities in
this area and he believes the entire state were in a similar position. Mr.
White stated that all proper procedures were followed everything was
documented, the hot line was called as required and letters followed up
immediately. Mr. White stated that he would be surprised if any enforcement
action was taken. Mr. White asked if there were any questions on what occurred.
I-Iearing none he moved on.
o & M Cost - Septage
Receiving Program
Mr. White stated that he had a request from Mr. Carroll to provide him
with the costs associated with the liquid acceptance program. Mr. White stated
that there is a draft letter in all the Commissioners files. Mr. White stated
that it is still in draft form as he wanted everyone to review the letter; to
see if you would like anything added or deleted. Mr. White stated that he has
broken it down into five categories.
The Chairman stopped Mr. White in his report and asked Mr. Miller ifthis can be addressed in Closed Session as it relates to
contractual issues. Mr. Miller stated that yes it would be a valid issue for
Closed Session,
TreesNegetation Plans
Mr. White stated with regard to trees and vegetation; if you recall in
the past several months there has been discussion with the residents
ofthe Wanaque Development and this Authority as well
as the Borough with regard to planting some additional trees and/or vegetation
around the facility and within the facility grounds. Mr. White reported that
there have been two meetings - in attendance were himself, Mr.
REPORTS
Facilities Manager TreesNegetation Plans Cont.
Mayor Dan Mahler stated that regarding this topic he would like to
inform the Commissioners that the Waters Edge project, in Haskell, is going to
be clearing the whole side of that mountain. He stated that any tree they
remove that is over 12" in diameter, they are going to be required to replace.
He stated that they are only going to be able to replace a limited amount of
trees in that development. One of the things that may occur is that they will
need to have a place to plant the remaining trees here in town. The Mayor
stated that this is a possible source of trees, as they have to plant them
somewhere. He stated that they still have to go before the Planning Board and
then DEP so this is not going to happen tomorrow, but it is down the road. Mr.
White stated that there will be additional discussion on this subject and that
he will probably be meeting in another two weeks with Mr. Holt, Mr. Farrantino
and Anthony with regard to this subject.
Compressor
Mr. White reported that we have a portable air compressor which we tow
around with our truck. We use the compressor to blow down our final clarifier
siphon collector units and we use it around the facility for general purposes.
Mr. White stated that the compressor is over twenty (20) years old and has been
repaired so many times that it is just shot. He stated that it is a 190 CFM
compressor, the standard is about 175 CFM. Mr. White stated that the bottom
line is that we need a new one very quickly. Mr. White stated that we have been
borrowing the Borough's this past week, but we need this device on a daily
basis and it does not lend itself to borrowing. Mr. White stated that he would
like to get approval to go out and look for a used one. He stated that he had
some feelers out to some local contractors that may be looking to get rid of
one. Mr. White stated that he believes it will cost between $6,000.00 and
$8,000.00, for a used one. Mr. White stated that he had not looked into a new
one. Discussion ensued. The Chairman suggested that Mr. White should ask Mr.
Carroll to find out ifthere is a State Contractor for
this item and what the price would be. The consensus was that Mr. White should
look into a new one rather than a used one. Mr. White stated that in the
interim he will continue to borrow the Borough's unit and if that is not
possible he will rent one.
St.
Catherine's - Ringwood
Mr. White reported that he has been contacted by Father Pat, the Pastor
at St. Catherine's Church in Ringwood. Mr. White explained that they have a
water system servicing the school, rectory and other buildings. Mr. White
reported that they have requested that he or the WVRSA be the licensed operator
for their water system. Mr. White stated that he has no problem doing that as
it would entail just a few hours of his time per year. Mr. White stated that he
has the proper license to do so and they have requested that we perform the
service for them. Discussion ensued. Some things discussed was the legality of
performing this at no cost for a religious entity; what would be the most
nominal charge for such a service and will this open a door for other
non-profit entities to come through. Mr. Miller stated that he would look into
the legal questions. Mr. White stated that he would develop a cost estimate for
this service. Mr. Boswell, our engineer added that Mr. White might want to
check with DEP as there may be a maximum number of entities you are allowed to
serve on that license. Mr. White stated that he would look into that.
DEP -
Planning Process
Mr. White stated that, as reported in the newspapers recently, regarding
DEP's proposed amendments to the Planning process;
they propose placing a Category 1 protection to numerous waterways within the
state of
REPORTS
Facilities
Manager
CPR Course
Mr. White reported that all the employees ofWRSA and the Chairman were certified for CPR, for a two
year period. He reported that
Chairman Covelli reported that he had taken advantage of the opportunity
and took the training course here at the Authority and became certified in both
the First Aid and the CPR. He stated that part of the presentation was a
demonstration of the AED by a member of the 1 sl Aid Ambulance Corp. Chairman
Covelli reported that part of the discussion he had with Mr. White was that as
we have a 24/7 operation and we have staff here at all times, we have
situations that could emerge where a member of our staff or the public that
uses this facility could be in need of this unit. He stated that both he and
Mr. White are in complete agreement that we should have an AED at the
Authority. Mr. White stated that he will contact Mr. Carroll to see ifthere is a State Contract Vendor for this equipment.
MOTION
Moved by
Joseph Elcavage, 2nd by Patrick Murray to
adopt a resolution to immediately purchase an Automatic External Defibrillator
for the Authority, with Mr. Carroll, our Certified Public Purchaser, to do so
at the least cost possible and to be sure that it is the most up-dated version
of the equipment.
On Roll Call
Commissioners Bolduc, Elcavage, Hadley, Murray and
Covelli voted yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
Plant and Septage Receipt
Mr. White reported that the plant is running extremely well. The septage receipt is going very strong with the exception
that we had to close for four (4) days due to the April 161h rain
event.
New Gate
Commissioner Elcavage asked Mr. White for a
status report on the new gate. Mr. White reported that the gate is working
fine, but we still have concern with the EZ Pass system. Mr. White reported
that the vendor was here again today. Mr. White explained that the card should
be able to be read a minimum of 8ft away. He stated that right now it can only
be read at a distance of 2 - 3 feet. Mr. White stated that the vendor is not
sure why that is occurring, so the vendor has sent a couple of the cards back
to the manufacturer to determine if they are defective. Mr. White stated that
is the only issue - the distance at which the EZ Pass card can be read everything
else is working fine. Mr. White reported that we put a phone/intercom system on
the outside so we can open the gate from inside the facility, at any phone
within the
facility.
The Chairman stated that at the last meeting, Mr. White stated that he
was withholding any further payments and ifthis was
still the case. Mr. White responded that they have not been paid another cent.
Mr. White stated that his report was complete other than one item he had
for Closed Session regarding Personnel.
Accounting
The Chairman stated that he would dispense with the Accounting Report
due to the absence of the Accountant. He then asked for the Engineering Report.
Engineering
Mr. Kevin Boswell of Boswell Engineering stated that he would like to
follow up on what Jim Kelly had said at the last meeting. Mr. Boswell stated
that his firm is very pleased to have been appointed Consulting Engineers for
the Authority and we look forward to serving you.
Water Edge- Wastewater Management Plan Amendment
Mr. Boswell stated that his firm was
asked to sit with the Board to make sure that any waivers are done
correctly. Mr Bosell stated that on April 23rd he received
from Bill Kelly a document that stated that a revision of the WMP would be
necessary in the not too distant future.
REPORTS Engineering
Waters Edge - Wastewater Management Plan Amendment Cont.
He stated that with the new C-I designations that Mr. White spoke about
earlier, that are coming out - the planning areas - they all need to be
reflected in the WMP revision. There are some substantial changes that can
affect the full build out with the realistic development potential of the
surface area.
Noise and
Odor Control Proposal
Mr. Boswell
stated that the one deliverable that he was asked to provide was a proposal
to evaluate the Noise and Odor
issue, in further support of what Mr. White has been doing so far. He stated
that they submitted a proposal dated Aprill9tl" which is essentially a
five-step proposal. Mr. Boswell stated that the first two are for interviewing
Mr. White and other plant personnel to see where the anticipated changes could
occur to best initiate some sort of improvements in those areas. The second
task would be to physically go out and view what is out there in the field such
as piping and various operations and to see what available areas there are to
relocate such items as the Septage Receiving Area;
which is the one area that has been discussed specifically. Mr. Boswell stated
that the area on the south side, down by the phosphorus reactor, we may be able
to be utilize some of those tanks for that purpose. Mr. Boswell stated that
when we look at that we would obviously be looking at the revised truck access
to inside the plant. Mr. Boswell stated that the ancillary benefits to the
plant process itself - to have a regulated flow coming in because, as we know,
the septage comes in as a slug, both in terms of
volume as well as the quality of waste that is coming in. Mr. Boswell stated
that this will give Mr. White a much better handle on what will be coming in
and how to address it .
Mr. Boswell stated that they will be making specific recommendations
under that note and the last thing was that we will prepare a report to you
that would talk about costs, estimates for design and construction for all
recommended facilities. The proposal will not include detail design, foundation
investigation, permits or surveys. Discussion ensued.
Commissioner Elcavage asked, when you prepared
this proposal did you have a cost estimate of what this project would be. Mr.
Boswell stated he and Mr. Rossi have discussed what it would cost to set up a
wet well with a pump system and a control vessel that Mr. White could regulate
flow into the plant. He stated that the cost of that would be between
$200,000.00 and $400,000.00 probably around $250,000.00 depending on constmction. Mr. Boswell stated that he did not want to
start throwing numbers around yet.
Mr. Rossi stated that you might take into consideration the tank that is
out there - using the existing tank with minor modifications will of course
help cut the price down, but depending on where the taking of that inner
structure out, which was part of the phosphorus tank, what happens when you
remove that structure. He asked, what will be the
structural integrity of that tank and what modifications will have to be made
to that tank. He stated that it might not be feasible and you might have to
build another tank alongside that tank and that is where the costs will start
to incur.
Mr. White stated that as some of you may not have been on the Board back
in the late '80s and early '90's when this tank in question was built as part
of the Housing Group Module, that tank was intended for phosphorus removal
purposes, it is actually a solids contact treatment unit. Mr. White stated that
recently he had a conversation with Mr. Ed Stevens, of Boswell Engineering, and
he made a very good point. Mr. Stevens said that if that tank is converted to a
holding tank we would loose the capability to remove phosphoms
- it cannot be used for its intended purposes; it would be dedicated as a
holding or septage receiving tank. Mr. White stated
that he has no concern with that, because we remove phosphorus within the main
treatment plant. Mr. White stated that we have phosphorus removal chemical feed
system within the main facility, which we just upgraded with the recent
construction project. He stated that we have been removing phosphorus and
complying with a 1.0 mg/llimit since 1989. Mr. White
stated that he is fully confident that we can continue to do so in the future
if the limitation is reduced to a reasonable level. He stated that we have been
averaging a 0.15mg/l phosphorus effluent concentration for 18 years.
Mr. Boswell stated that his firm is capable of doing an analysis on the
structure. He also stated that by moving this process 200 feet further away and
with the vegetative cover he feels this will be a viable project. The noise
control factor was discussed again and it was stated that there are decibel
readings prior to this development going up in this area that we can use them
to compare with.
REPORTS Engineering
Noise and
Odor Control Proposal Cont.
Chairman Covelli stated that the proposal looks good and asked what the
time table was for his report. Mr. Boswell stated approximately sixty (60)
days. He stated that the decibel studies will be included without any extra
charges. The Chairman stated that he thinks that everyone on the Board agrees
that we need some benchmarks and we welcome you on board because it is time to
evaluate where we are, so we can plan appropriately where we need to be.
The Chairman
asked if there was a motion to accept the proposal.
MOTION
Moved by
Joseph Elcavage, 2nd by Andrew Bolduc to adopt a
resolution to accept the Boswell Engineering Proposal for a Wastewater
Treatment Plant Odor and Noise Study, as presented, at a cost not to exceed
$11,500.00.
On Roll Call
Commissioners Bolduc, Elcavage, Hadley, Murray and
Covelli voted yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
Mr. Rossi gave
a report on the situation regarding the
He stated that
Bill Kelly is working diligently on getting emergency permits from the State.
Mr. Rossi stated that they have informed Mr. Bill Kelly that they are available
for support should he need it. Mr. White stated that Bill Kelly is soliciting
proposals from five contractors to do the work as well. Mr. Rossi stated that their
report was completed.
The Chairman
called for the Legal Report.
Legal
Inflow and
Infiltration 0&1) Work
Mr. Miller stated that following up on the I & I work, one of the things he
is working on is the 2nd Amendment to the Developers Agreement, with
regard to the payment for this work. Mr. Miller stated that the WBSA is really
carrying the ball principally on this. Mr. Miller stated that he has received
several emails from Pulte's Counsel- they haven't made a final decision yet.
Mr. Miller stated that the issue being a minimum of$50,000.00 that they would
contribute and that they are being asked to put the money up front; so we will
be spending their money first. Mr. Miller stated that we have not gotten a
response on that. Mr. Miller reported that they have asked if we had anything
to add at tonight's meeting and according to Mr. White we have some minor
things but nothing major that would change the form of the agreement. Mr.
Miller stated that hopefully that will be resolved in a week or so.
Litigation
Borough of
Ringwood
Mr. Miller reported that we have a firm date for the first mediation
session on the Ringwood litigation. He stated that there will be a conference
call mediation hearing on May 10, 2007 at 4:00 pm with the mediator. Mr. Miller
stated that he will need a representative of the Authority to take part in that
telephone conference who can speak with some authority. Mr. Miller stated that
if we are going to go into Closed Session, he would like to go into more detail
at that time on strategy.
Mr. Miller stated that his report was completed and the Chairman asked
for the Voucher Report.
Vouchers
RE: Vouchers
M-I0272 thru M-I0325 - FY '07
All payments subject to availability offunds.
RESOLUTION - Read by Title
“RESOLUTION
REQUISITIONING FROM THE REVENUE FUND TO THE REVOLVING FUND BY THE WANAQUE
VALLEY REGIONAL SEWERAGE AUTHORITY (“AUTHORITY”) PURSUANT TO SECTION 506 OF THE
BOND RESOLUTION ENTITLED “RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS OF THE
WANAQUE VALLEY REGIONAL SEWERAGE AUTHORITY AND FOR THE RIGHTS OF THE HOLDERS
THEREOF, AND AUTHORIZING $12,500,000.00 PRINCIPAL AMOUNT THEREOF (“RESOLUTION”)
ADOPTED BY THE AUTHORITY ON AUGUST 26, 1987, AS AMENDED OR SUPPLEMENTED
THEREAFTER”
REPORTS
Vouchers Cont.
MOTION
Moved by Joseph Elcavage,
2nd by Patrick Murray to adopt a resolution to approve payment of Vouchers
M-10272, thru M-10325 for FY '07 with all payments subject to availability of
funds.
On Roll Call Commissioners
Bolduc, Elcavage Hadley, Murray and Covelli voted
yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
OLD
BUSINESS
The Chairman asked if there was anything to be discussed under Old
Business. When there was no response, he stated he would move onto New
Business.
NEW
BUSINESS
The Chairman asked if there was anything to be discussed under New
Business. When there was no response he stated that he would open the meeting
to the Public.
PUBLIC
PORTION
The Chairman stated that at this time he would like
to open the meeting to the public. He stated that anyone that would like to
address this Board to step up to the microphone and identify themselves.
Daniel Mahler, Mayor of Wanaque - Mayor Mahler asked for permission to address the
Board in Closed Session, on his subject related to contract negotiations.
Permission was granted and the Mayor took his seat.
Mr. Holt stated that he would like to again thank Mr. White for his
effort in cutting back some of the noise by our pointing out that he had a
noisy bearing on the odor control system and having it corrected immediately
and also attempting, on a trial business right now, of tuming
off the equipment at night. He stated that it may not be needed any longer and
what Mr. White has done now is created a situation where we now hear how loud
these frogs are around here and it is wonderful. Mr. Holt stated that there
have been some very peaceful nights.
The Chairman informed Mr. Holt that we will do everything we can do on
odor and noise but we cannot control the frogs. The Chairman asked Mr. Holt,
with regard to your "good neighbor" policy, did he have a specific
proposal or process in mind. The Chairman asked if they had a functioning Board
to sit down with for these types of discussions.
The Chairman stated that he, speaking as himself, would be happy to
schedule with your Board or with you as liaison, for a time that he and Mr.
White would come to meet with you on a prescribed basis; possibly on a monthly
basis - at a mutually convenient time for all parties.
Mr. Holt stated that the Ad Hoc committee represents
some of the Wanaque Reserve residents, not necessarily all of them, because it
is an Ad Hoc committee. Mr. Holt stated that the official Board of the Wanaque
Reserve Association, is still controlled by Pulte, therefore, we cannot have
someone from that Board interact with you at this time, because you are still
negotiating with Pulte, therefore, it is a conflict of interest there. That is
why we still are an Ad Hoc committee. Mr. Holt stated that for the time being,
for the type of issues we have discussed here, it has to be with the Ad Hoc
committee. He stated that once the residents are in control of the Board then
the conflict of interest goes away.
Mr. Miller concurred that until there is a transition from Pulte to the
Condo owners, Pulte is still in control of the
situation.
The Chairman stated considering the familiarity that we have with one
and another over time, his offer still stands. He stated that he believes that
Mr. White would not be too angry for him for volunteering him, as he will go
with him to these meetings. The Chairman stated that we will coordinate a set
interval to meet over coffee where we can discuss these matters.
The Chairman
asked if there was anyone else that wished to address the Board at this time.
Upon hearing none he would ask for a motion to close the Public Portion.
MOTION
Moved by Joseph Elcavage, 2nd by
Patrick Murray to adopt a resolution to close the Public Portion of this
meeting.
The Chairman
asked for all those in favor to reply by saying Aye, and asked for any opposed
or abstentions.
All
Commissioners present stated Aye. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
The Chairman
stated that he would entertain a motion to go into Closed Session for the
purposes of contract negotiations, litigation, and personnel business. He
stated that there may be some action taken upon returning to Open Session. The
Chairman stated that he would like to thank the Engineers and dismiss them for
the evening. The ChaiIman stated that Mr. Miller will
be required to stay and that Mayor Mahler is invited to join us. The Mayor
suggested that the Engineer stay as he may have some valuable information.
MOTION
Moved by
Patrick Murray, 2nd by Joseph Elcavage
to adopt a resolution to go into Closed Session for the purposes of contract
negotiations, litigation report and personnel business and that there may be
some action taken upon the return to Open Session.
The Chairman
asked for all those in favor to reply by saying Aye, and asked for any opposed
or abstentions.
All
Commissioners present stated Aye. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
Closed Session
commenced at 7:10 pm and was concluded at 8:05 pm with the following motion.
MOTION
Moved by Joseph Elcavage, 2nd by Patrick Murray to adopt a
resolution to return to Open Session.
On Roll Call
Commissioners Bolduc, Elcavage, Hadley, Murray and
Covelli voted yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
The ChaiIman stated that
based on the discussion held in Closed Session, we have an issue with regard to
the litigation with the Borough of Ringwood that will be coming up on a
mediation conference on May 10th• The Chairman asked if there
was a motion on that issue.
MOTION Moved by Joseph Elcavage,
2nd by Robert Hadley to adopt a resolution appointing
Andrew Bolduc,
with an alternate of Robert Moshman, to be representatives in the litigation
discussions along with a representative of Mr. Miller's office on May 10,2007
at 4:00 pm
The Chairman
asked if there was any discussion on the motion. Upon hearing none he asked for
a Roll Call.
On Roll Call
Commissioners Bolduc, Elcavage, Hadley, Murray and
Covelli voted yes. Commissioner Moshman was absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
The Chariman
stated with regard to a personnel issue he asked Mr. White to respond. Timothy Johnson. Mr. White stated that based upon a successful
performance evaluation on April 11th , he recommends that Mr.
Johnson be removed from probationary status and placed on non-probationary
status, effective April 11, 2007 and that he receive the corresponding hourly
wage increase and all benefits afforded all non-probationary employees.
