REGIONAL
SEWERAGE AUTHORITY MEETING
MINUTES
May 27, 2009
Regular Meeting
The WANAQUE VALLEY REGIONAL SEWERAGE AUTHORITY
conducted a Regular Meeting, which commenced 6:14 p.m., in the
ANNOUNCEMENT
Mrs. Maas, Recording Secretary read the following
announcement:
This
is the Regular Meeting of the Wanaque Valley Regional Sewerage Authority. In accordance with the Open Public Meeting
Law, notices of the meeting were furnished to the respective Municipal Clerks
of Ringwood, Wanaque and West Milford together with a
request that an additional copy of the Notice be placed in each
SALUTE TO THE FLAG
The Chairman led the Salute to the Flag.
The Chairman stated for the record that that he
would like to apologize for this meeting starting late this evening. He stated that there were some last-minute
things that came up that we wanted to include on tonight's agenda.
ROLL CALL
Commissioners present: Harry Clark, Robert Hadley, Robert Moshman and Frank Covelli
Commissioners absent: Andrew Bolduc and Patrick Murray
Also present: Richard Miller,
Esq., Williams, Caliri, Miller and Otley
Charles Ferraioli, Jr., Ferraioli
Wielkotz, Cerullo & Cuva
James Kelly, P. E., Boswell
Engineering
Gregory
White, Facilities Manager
Margaret
Maas, Recording Secretary
CORRESPONDENCE
The
Chairman stated that everyone has in their folder a
copy of the Correspondence List for the period of 04-17-09 thru 5-20-09. He asked if anyone had any corrections, comments or questions regarding this list. Upon receiving no response, he stated that
the Correspondence List would be placed on file.
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES 04-22-09
MOTION Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd by Harry Clark to adopt the
resolution accepting the April 22, 2009 Regular Meeting Minutes.
The
Chairman asked for all those in favor to signify so by saying Aye.
Commissioners
Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all stated Aye
Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
CLOSED SESSION MINUTES 03-25-09
MOTION
Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd
by Harry Clark to adopt the resolution accepting the March 25, 2009 Closed
Session Minutes. It was stated that due
to the nature of these minutes, they will not be
released to the public until the reason for the Closed Session has been
concluded
The
Chairman asked for all those in favor to signify so by saying Aye.
Commissioners
Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all stated Aye
Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
CLOSED SESSION MINUTES 04-22-09
MOTION
Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd
by Harry Clark to adopt the resolution accepting the April 22, 2009 Closed
Session Minutes. It was stated that due to the nature
of these minutes, they will not be released to the
public until the reason for the Closed Session has been concluded.
The
Chairman asked for all those in favor to signify so by saying Aye.
Commissioners
Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all stated Aye
Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
CONSENT AGENDA
Chairman stated that he would like to add Resolution
#35-09 to the Consent Agenda. He stated that he would
give further explanation and information during Mr. White's report. The Chairman stated that this resolution would authorize
us becoming a member of the Sustainable Energy Joint Meeting. Mr. Miller suggested that Resolution # 32-09
be removed from the Consent
Agenda and that it be addressed as a separate resolution. The Chairman stated that that resolution will
be removed and that it will be addressed during Mr. Miller's Legal Report. The Chairman asked if there are any additions, deletions or comments on the balance of the Consent
Agenda. Upon hearing none, He stated
that he is going to take the reports out of order this evening, as Mr. Ferraioli has another meeting to attend this evening and he
is going to ask him to report first.
REPORTS
Accounting
Federal
Stimulus Bill
Mr.
Ferraioli distributed copies of a two-page document
from the New Jersey Environmental Infrastructure Trust Fund - Fund Programs
Financing (NJEIF)
to all the Commissioners. Mr. Ferraioli
stated that this is amortization run of the Stimulus money
that we are looking to fund. Mr. Ferraioli stated that the documents portray that this is all based upon the assumption that we will receive a
Grant of certain dollars and the balance of money that was not forgivable we
would borrow 75% of that balance at 0% interest and 25% at market state
interest value. Mr. Ferraioli
stated our currently planned upgrade, according to N.J.D.E.P.,
is $2,999,000.00. Mr. Ferraioli pointed out to that this document also shows
there is a 2% DEP state fee on these funds, which
amounts to $59,800.00.
He stated that every grant, every loan that comes through the
Infrastructure Trust, DEP takes 2% off the top. Mr. Ferraioli also explained
that he has capitalized the Interest of $27,615.57, which gives us time to
complete the project before the Debt Service kicks in. He
stated that this also puts the debt service payments into our 2011 Budget
instead of 2010.
Mr.
Ferraioli stated that we have not moved on this yet,
as the applications for the Financial Addendum are due in
Mr. Ferraioli stated that
the Commissioners at any point have the option of walking away if we do not
receive a forgiveness grant or for any other reason
Mr.
Ferraioli then went over the
amortization figures and what it would cost if we were to borrow the total
amount. He stated that he does
not believe that we will have to borrow all of the $2,990,000.00
as he believes that we will be funded.
Mr.
Ferraioli stated that if we do not
get funded and need to borrow the funds it could mean an increase in the
2010 budget of $185,000.00 and then it would be a no go.
REPORTS
Accounting
Federal Stimulus Bill Cont.
There
was discussion on some of the ways the Authority could possibly save some money
by implementing some of the planned projects immediately.
Mr. Ferraioli
stated that at some point in time the Commissioners must decide if we should
move forward, if we do not get any funding from the state. He stated that he did not need an answer
tonight, but we will need it soon. There
was further discussion.
Mr.
Ferraioli asked if there were any questions. Upon receiving no response he
stated that his report was completed.
Mr.
Ferraioli stated that he would like the Commissioners
to be advised that the professional staff, including those present and the Bond
Counsel, have been working very hard on this project and on getting this
funding in place and will continue to do so.
The
Chairman thanked Mr. Ferraioli for his report an
excused him for the evening.
Facilities
Manager
Noise
& Odor Control Report – Update
Mr.
White stated that everyone should have a copy of the Noise and Odor Control
Report in their folders. Mr. White
reported that all the odor control units are operating very well. He stated that we have not needed the misters. Mr. White stated that to the best of his
knowledge the Authority has not received any odor complaints over the past
month.
PMK Energy Consultant - Effluent Reuse Report
Mr.
White stated that everyone has received a copy of the Wastewater Reuse
Feasibility Report, it was sent to your homes in your
packages. Mr. White asked the
Commissioners to review the report and it will be discussed at the next meeting. The Chairman asked if Mr. Kelly received a copy also. Mr. White said he did not but that he would see that he
gets one before the end of the meeting.
WMMUA – Shared Service Agreement
Mr.
White reported that there was a lot back-and-forth between Chris Erd, of Williams, Caliri, Miller
& Otley, Mr. Miller and Mr. Baum, the attorney
for the West Milford MUA. Mr.
White stated that Chairman Covelli did not
participate but did make sure everyone was talking. Mr. White stated that we finally came to a
consensus on the Agreement and West Milford MUA
approved the Agreement last night, however, they did not sign it last night.
Mr.
Miller stated that he has signature copies with him this evening, to be signed
from our end, if we agree to authorize
the agreement and he stated that we would also be authorizing the
Vice-Chairman, Mr. Hadley to execute the agreement on our behalf, as the
Chairman has recused himself from any consideration
in this matter.
REPORTS
Facilities
Manager
WMMUA – Shared Service Agreement Cont.
NOTE:
Chairman Covelli stated that at this time it might be
appropriate to address something that occurred at the March meeting relative to
this agreement. He stated that he believed that there
was some back-and-forth on some minutes from the meeting that was held on March
25, 2009. The Chairman stated that he inadvertently
voted on an issue relative to this contract, which he had made known early on,
that he did not want to be involved.
Therefore, for the record, he would like to change that vote, strike it
to vote an Abstention, relative to that issue. The
Chairman asked that this be noted in the Minutes. The Chairman stated that it would not change
the outcome of that vote. Mr. Miller
agreed that it will not be a deciding vote. Mr. White added that we will not actually
change the Minutes the March meeting, we will just reflect here what you have
said. The Chairman stated that he thinks
there should be a notation added to the March Minutes, that there has been a
change, otherwise, years from now someone reading those Minutes would not know
to look two months later to reflect that a change was made.
Mr.
White stated that he had a conversation this afternoon with Miss Kehr, of the MUA, and she has
promised that the Chairman of the MUA will sign the
Agreement within the next day or two and that she will immediately forward to me the original for Mr. Hadley to sign. Mr. White stated that we will
then be in business and ready for a June 1st start. Mr. Miller said that the Agreement is very straight forward and is exactly what we had stated, there
were no changes required on either side.
Ringwood
Borough -
Mr. White reported that this Agreement was executed
during the past month and we started working up at the
facility at the beginning of May and that everything has been going
extremely well. Mr. White stated than
normally there is a rocky period of time during a
transition, however, this was a splendid transition and we have not had one
single problem, things are going well.
Mr. White stated that copies, of that Agreement, are available should
anyone wished to receive a signed version of it.
Personnel
Report – Curt Graves
Mr.
White reported that Mr. Graves recently attained his C-3 NJDEP
Collection System Operator's license.
Mr. White stated that as per the Personnel Policy Manual Mr. Graves is
entitled to receive a$ 0.50 per hour wage increase. Mr. White stated that as per Resolution 34-09
on the Consent Agenda his hourly wage will increase from $31.16 to 31.66 per
hour and that it is retroactive to May 14, 2009. Mr. White stated that he was
sent a congratulatory letter. Mr.
White stated that it is an honor for one to get that license.
CPR
Class – June 18th
Mr.
White stated that the CPR class is scheduled to be held on June 18th and that anyone wishing to become certified
is welcome to attend. Mr. White stated
that letters will be sent, inviting the Wanaque Borough and the WBSA employees to attend.
REPORTS
Facilities
Manager
CPR
Class – June 18th Cont.
The
Chairman asked Mr. White if there was a limit to size of the Class. Mr. White stated that he believed there was a
limit but that he feels we are well below that limit. The Chairman stated that West Milford MUA has asked him if we were planning on
doing the CPR course this year and if so they would like to attend, if
there is space. The Chairman stated that
he advised them that should there be openings they would be required to pay
their own way and they agreed. The Chairman stated that he felt to
it would be the neighborly thing to do and as it will cost us nothing, and that
he hoped the other Commissioners would agree with him.
Liquid
Waste Acceptance
Mr.
White stated that the Liquid Waste acceptance is going extremely well and
stated that we have been very busy. Mr.
White stated that it looks like the month of May will the first time that we
break the $100,000.00 mark for a month.
Mr. White stated that he is hoping that we will start to catch up on and
recoup some of the lost revenue we experienced during this severe winter. Mr. White reported that everything is running
extremely well, not only here but also with the Ringwood Board of Education
Plant and Ringwood Borough Plants as well.
Mr. White stated that his report was completed.
Engineering
The
Chairman asked Mr. Kelly if he would explain the New Jersey Infrastructure Fund
Program, as the Pompton Lakes MUA got a front page
story in the Suburban Trends, but the West Milford MUA
and the Wanaque Valley Regional Sewerage Authority which were also approved but
were nowhere to be found. He asked Mr. Kelly to
explain for the public that this Authority has not been asleep at the switch,
but in fact
worked very hard to apply for the
Stimulus and are on list for funding.
Mr.
Kelly stated that the Chairman is correct that this Authority has worked hard
and he thinks that this Authority should be commended; as was just reported by
Mr. Ferraioli, you have done whatever was necessary
and possible to do, in order to complete the application properly, completely
and in a timely manner. Mr. Kelly stated that he would
be interesting in hearing Mr. Miller’s thoughts on this matter.
Mr.
Miller stated that he has never worked so hard on trying to find out what the
State wanted in the application. He says it was very
confusing and complex and that he believes with the help of all the
professionals that this Authority has accomplished the task.
Mr.
Kelly stated that this Authority was ahead of the curve by a great deal Mr. Kelly stated he had complemented Mr. Ferraioli beforehand on his submission – the package - that
documents what he'd spoken about earlier this evening was so extremely
comprehensive that there were no questions to be asked. Mr. Kelly stated that this Authority is on
the cutting edge and that he truly expects that we will get the money.
REPORTS
Engineering
Mr.
Kelly stated that the Authority just missed the cut off point of projects that are guaranteed. He
stated that both he and Mr. Ferraioli agree that
there is no reason not to believe that the funding will be
granted. Mr. Kelly stated that
there are only four projects ahead of us; they are up
to #94 and we are #98. Mr. Kelly also
stated that he did not believe that the project will
cost the entire $2,990,000.00 as projected.
Mr. Kelly explained that the DEP in an effort
to be conservative, to cover contingencies for all projects came up with these
amounts. Mr. Kelly stated that he believes that they
want to make sure there's enough for all
contingencies; change orders, bidding situations, etc. He stated we're not
sure how they came up with this number, but they did.
Mr.
Kelly stated that one of the items on your Consent Agenda this evening is
Resolution # 33-09 – 2009 NJEIF Recommitment
Certification. He stated that this
resolution authorizes the submission of the necessary recommitment to the
project.
Mr. Kelly stated that there have been several
applicants, due to various reasons, that no longer wish to participate. Mr. Kelly stated that the DEP
would like a current, as of May 2009, recommitment of your earlier, February 2009,
commitment. Mr. Kelly stated that we must move as
quickly as we can to be responsive and be ready to go. Mr. Kelly stated that we are optimistic that
we will be reached, we're optimistic that we will
receive payment around July or August and Mr. White will be able to go out to
bid by October. Mr. Kelly stated that we
need to be ready when they're ready.
Mr.
Kelly reported that we need one additional piece of paper now from the
Highlands Commission. He stated that we
relocated the Receiving System to the southern portion of the plant and we are
going to use the old storage tanks that have never been used.
Mr. Kelly stated that in this area that we are
going to put the new receiving pit
and we are going to be
disturbing grass areas and for that we need the OK from the Highlands
Commission. Mr. Kelly does not foresee
any problem with this.
Mr.
Kelly reported that everything is well along in it’s proper pace. He stated that Bond Counsel has gone overboard in making
sure everything is prepared and presented properly.
Commissioner
Hadley asked Mr. Kelly what was the estimated time target for completion. Mr. Kelly stated
that should take about nine months to complete, but that it depends on what
happens with this winter.
The
Chairman commented that had it not been for the introduction of this Stimulus
Fund, we would have been under way already as we did have the funding in place,
but when that offer was presented to have 50% of this project paid for through
federal money; we opted to wait and made our application. He
stated that this Authority invested $35,000 .00 in an attempt to receive
$1,500,000.00 and it appears we are on the right track.
REPORTS
Engineering
Mr.
White asked the Chairman if he would like him to look into getting some
newspaper coverage for this Authority.
The Chairman stated that as we do not have the guaranteed funding in
hand as of yet, although we are as close as we could possibly get; once we
know, in writing, that we are funded -
if the newspapers do not pick it up we will make sure they know about
it. Mr.
Kelly stated that his report was completed.
Chairman
Covelli stated that for the record
the PMK has our Carbon Foot Print ready and has
completed our energy consumption footprint. The Chairman stated that in accordance with
the Governor’s initiative of a year and a half ago we
are to mark our Carbon Foot Print and he has charged all entities with reducing
that Carbon Foot Print by 20%. He stated
that we have been already doing some things, and before we do
any more we wanted to mark that point, so that we don't complete the reduction
and are then told to measure it and then want us to go another 20%. The Chairman stated that we want to be able
to show that we've done what was asked.
Mr.
White added that the power factor is being investigated
by JCP &.L, but it needs more evaluation. Mr. White reported that we are replacing all the lights
fixtures in the facility and the cost of replacing the light bulbs and the
fixtures will be coming out of the project money.
Legal
Mr.
Miller stated the best of his recollection we do not have a formal motion on
the West Milford MUA Sludge Disposal Agreement on
record.
The
Chairman asked Mr. Miller to recap the Agreement for the public. Mr. Miller stated that this Agreement deals with the
treatment of the West Milford MUA Sludge, which is to
be trucked here and that they are going to pay us
$45.00 per thousand gallons delivered.
In addition we are going to get the use of
their truck, with a driver, to do a grease transfer for us once a month. Mr. Miller stated that according to Mr. White
the use of their truck will save us $18,000.00 over
the course of the year. Mr. Miller
stated that the agreement will contain all of the indemnification and insurance
clauses that we had asked for. Mr. Miller stated that it is a
nineteen-month contract, which will run from June 1, 2009 through December 31,
2010, which coincides with our contract with Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners, with respect to our current disposal rate. Mr. Miller stated that he would like a formal
motion approving this agreement and authorizing Robert Hadley, Vice-Chairman to
execute the same on behalf of this Authority.
Mr. White reported that according to our requirements they have secured
a secondary disposal site for their sludge should they not be able to bring it
here for whatever reason. The Chairman
stated that he wished to have it noted that this contract form is consistent
with what we did for the James Drive Plant and which has become our standard
format.
REPORTS
Legal Cont.
MOTION Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd by Robert Moshman to adopt Resolution #32-09, approving the West
Milford MUA Sludge Disposal Agreement
and
authorizing Robert Hadley, Vice- Chairman to execute the document on behalf of
the Wanaque Valley Regional Sewerage Authority
. On Roll Call Commissioners
Clark, Hadley, and Moshman all voted yes.
Commissioner Covelli abstained. Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were absent.
MOTION
CARRIED
Records Request
Mr.
White reported that the Authority received a subpoena for records from the law
firm of Hetchka, Bachmaa
& Figundo, regarding our Risk Management
Consultant, Virginia Forde of McCarthy Forde, LLC. Mr. White stated that there was a thorough
search of our files, and we were not able to locate what they were requesting. Mr. White stated that he notified them in writing of the
same. Mr. Miller added that he also
searched for these documents they were requesting and
was equally unable locate any such documents.
WVRSA By-Law Amendment
Mr. Miller stated that he
would like to apologize that he did not have the proposed By-Laws amendment
ready. He stated that he had wanted to
have it completed and be able to have it circulated for at least five business
days before the meeting. He stated
hopefully he will have it ready for the next meeting. Mr.
Miller stated that the bulk of his time was taken up with the Engineer and the Bond Counsel and the preparation of the
Stimulus Fund application.
Mr.
Miller stated that his report was completed.
OLD BUSINESS
The Chairman asked there was any Old Business to be
discussed this evening. Upon receiving no response he stated that he would move onto New Business.
NEW BUSINESS
The Chairman asked if there was any new business to be discussed this evening,
Sustainable
Joint Meeting
The
Chairman stated that the NJUA-JIF, of which we are a
member and which is part of the statewide Municipal Excess Liability Fund
(MEL), has taken on an initiative to form a joint meeting for the purposes of Sustainable Energy. He stated that this group will
be called the Sustainable Energy Joint Meeting (SEM).
Sustainable Joint Meeting (SEM)
Cont.
The Chairman stated that a joint meeting is a public entity. He stated
that the public entities around the state will
join this SEM for
the purposes of securing and acquiring
electricity and natural
gas.
The Chairman reminded
everyone that PMK had attempted
to do this but was only able to get approximately one dozen other
entities to join. He stated
that it was decided the joint
meeting effort going
statewide, considering the MEL has 500 plus members state wide and that there is power in numbers, the more attractive the rates
will look.
The Chairman stated
that there is a one time fee of $600.00 to join the SEM. He
stated that the SEM will, on behalf of all of the public entities
entered, go out to bid
on electricity and gas and will use an electronic based bidding process,
which will include
the fees that are
required of the
professionals to run
the bid.
The Chairman stated
that the $600.00
fee will
be used to gather all of the information on the member public entities and create a database
such that Joint Meeting
can go out from
time to time and secure quotations.
The Chairman stated
that should this
Authority choose to
join the SEM, it will designate a contact person, which he suggested it be Mr. White
our Facilities Manager, and he would receive notification from the
Joint Meeting that
they're going out
to bid electricity. Mr.
White would then be told what the target amount is. If the amount
comes out above that
target amount
it will not be processed. At that time we can
elect or reject to be part of that bid cycle, if for example we had a more favorable rate. The Chairman
stated that if we do nothing we are automatically
included; we
must notify them
if we want to be excluded from a cycle, as we are always a member of the Joint Meeting. The Chairman
stated that he sees no down side to this. He stated
that there is a sense of urgency here to put this together and go out for bids in June. Discussion ensued. The conclusion
of the discussions
was that the Chairman stated that
there is a Resolution
#35-09 - authorizing joining the Sustainable Energy
Joint Meeting that
he hopes the Commissioners will act
favorably
upon. The Chairman
stated that he has additional printed
information, if anyone
would like copies
to review regarding
this. He stated
that there is also a web site available.
PUBLIC PORTION
The Chairman
stated that anyone
from the audience
that wishes to address the Board to please step forward and identify
themselves for the
record. Upon seeing no one, the Chairman asked for a motion to close the Public Portion of the meeting.
PUBLIC PORTION Cont.
MOTION Moved by Robert Hadley, 2nd by Harry Clark to adopt a resolution authorizing
closing the Public
Portion of this meeting.
The
Chairman asked all
those in favor to signify so by saying Aye.
Commissioners
Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all stated
Aye
Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were absent.
CONSENT AGENDA
The Chairman stated
that we have a Consent Agenda which consists of:
Resolution #
31-09 – Vouchers – M-11373 – M-11415
NOTE: Payment subject to availability of
funds
# 33-09 – 2009 NJEIF
Recommitment Certification
# 34-09 - Curt Graves Increase – C-3
License
# 35-09 - Joining Sustainable Energy
Joint Meeting
The Chairman
asked if anyone wanted discussion. Upon
hearing none he asked
for a motion to accept the Consent Agenda as presented
MOTION Moved
by Harry Clark, 2nd by a Robert Hadley to adopt a resolution
accepting the Consent
Agenda as stated.
On
Roll-Call Commissioners Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all voted
yes. Commissioners Bolduc and Murray were absent.
ADJOURN
The Chairman
asked for a motion to adjourn the meeting.
MOTION Moved by Harry Clark, 2ND by Robert
Hadley to adopt Resolution adjourning this
meeting.
The
Chairman asked for
all those in favor to signify so by saying Aye
. Commissioners Clark, Hadley, Moshman and Covelli all stated
Aye.
Commissioners
Bolduc and Murray were
absent.
The meeting was concluded at 7:20 pm.
Minutes
respectfully submitted by,
Margaret M.
Maas, Recording Secretary